UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT

FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OKLAHOMA

Chief Judge Terrence L. Michael

 


WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 23, 2017

11:00 AM

17-11106-M
 
Amber Elizabeth Stewart (Ch.7 )
Continued Telephonic Hearing regarding Motion of American Honda Finance Corporation for Relief from Stay and Abandonment of Property; Objection by Debtor
   Kelly Parker representing American Honda Finance Corporation
Michelle Matthews representing Amber Stewart
 


THURSDAY, AUGUST 24, 2017

10:00 AM

17-10639-M
 
Curtis Lynn Edwards and Carolyn Lucinda Wooten (Ch.7 )
**Continued to September 28, 2017**
United States Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 707(b); Objection by Debtors
Katherine Vance representing Office of the United States Trustee
Michelle Matthews representing Carolyn Wooten
Michelle Matthews representing Curtis Edwards
   
 


TUESDAY, AUGUST 29, 2017

10:00 AM

16-10678-M
 
Sheehan Pipe Line Construction Company (Ch.11)
Motion of Ohio River System LLC for Relief from Applicable Stay and/or Injunctions and Waiver of the 14-Day Stay of Bankruptcy Rule 4001(a)(3) (Docket No. 881); Response by The Sheehan Pipe Line Liquidating Trust (Docket No. 893)
   Mark Sanders representing Ohio River System LLC
Chad Kutmas representing Sheehan Pipe Line Construction Company
Mary Kindelt representing Sheehan Pipe Line Construction Company

17-10994-M
 
Tiffany Elizabeth Stripling (Ch.7 )
Debtor's Reaffirmation Agreement with Oklahoma Credit
   Tiffany Stripling, ProSe representing Tiffany Stripling

17-11212-M
 
Daniel Francis O'rourke, III and Wendy Kathleen O'rourke (Ch.7 )
Debtors' Reaffirmation Agreement with BOKF, N.A.
   Kelly Parker representing BOKF, N.A.
Daniel O'rourke, ProSe representing Daniel O'rourke
Wendy O'rourke, ProSe representing Wendy O'rourke

17-11556-M
 
Tracie Lynn Tennant (Ch.7 )
**Stricken as moot; Filing fee paid in full**
1) Debtor's Application for Individuals to Pay the Filing Fee in Installments;

2) Debtor's Motion to Dismiss Voluntary Petition
   J. Gallon representing Tracie Tennant
 

CHAPTER 13 DOCKET

 

FIRST TIME CONFIRMATION HEARINGS

02:00 PM

17-11117-M
 
Tricia Deeann Peoples (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   Brian Huckabee representing Tricia Peoples

17-11123-M
 
Santiago Jimmy Carrasco and Deanna Mancha Carrasco (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.; Objection by Trustee
   Kirk Cejda representing Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.
Michelle Matthews representing Deanna Carrasco
Michelle Matthews representing Santiago Carrasco

17-11142-M
 
Marcus C. Kight and Amanda C. Kight (Ch.13)
1) Confirmation Hearing; Objection by SANTANDER CONSUMER USA Inc.; Objection by TTCU The Credit Union; Objection by Trustee: Response to Objection of TTCU The Credit Union by Debtor
2) Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtors

ISSUES: Motion to Dismiss Pending
   Heather Buchberger representing SANTANDER CONSUMER USA Inc.
Collin Hinds representing TTCU The Credit Union
Charles Kania representing Amanda Kight
Charles Kania representing Marcus Kight

17-11194-M
 
Alexander Nhia Thao (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by JPMorgan Chase Bank; Objection by Trustee

ISSUES: Motion to Dismiss Pending
   Kirk Cejda representing JPMorgan Chase Bank, National Association
Haley Simmoneau representing Alexander Thao

17-11199-M
 
Vernon Lee Boswell,, Jr. and Teresa Dee Boswell (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   J. Gallon representing Teresa Boswell
J. Gallon representing Vernon Boswell,

17-11201-M
 
Michael Wayne Hawk and Tabitha Euvonna Hawk (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   J. Gallon representing Michael Hawk
J. Gallon representing Tabitha Hawk

17-11202-M
 
John David Anderson, Jr. and Michelle Renate Anderson (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Red Crown Federal Credit Union; Objection by Trustee
   David Wheeler representing Red Crown Federal Credit Union
Anna Hanson representing John Anderson
Anna Hanson representing Michelle Anderson

17-11210-M
 
Charles David Tollefsen (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Tulsa County Treasurer; Objection by Trustee
   Charles Tollefsen, ProSe representing Charles Tollefsen
Douglas Wilson representing J. Dennis Semler Tulsa County Treasurer

17-11218-M
 
Mary Anthony Reese (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   Wesley Thompson representing Mary Reese

17-11220-M
 
Jill Lynn Knox and Richard Charles Knox (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   Kent Siegrist representing Jill Knox
Kent Siegrist representing Richard Knox

17-11290-M
 
Tiffany Lynn Lumpkin (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   Tiffany Lumpkin, ProSe representing Tiffany Lumpkin

17-11305-M
 
Jonathan David Manuel (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   Greggory Colpitts representing Jonathan Manuel

17-11306-M
 
Jennifer Marie Mueller (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   Greggory Colpitts representing Jennifer Mueller

17-11355-M
 
James Richard Shea and Sharon Kay Shea (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee; Objection by Sterling, Inc. d/b/a Kay Jewelers
   Roger Everett representing Sterling, Inc. d/b/a Kay Jewelers
Stephen Bulleigh representing James Shea
Stephen Bulleigh representing Sharon Shea

17-11370-M
 
Keri Ann Alva (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   Greggory Colpitts representing Keri Alva

17-11373-M
 
Donnie Gene Howard (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   Brian Huckabee representing Donnie Howard

17-11376-M
 
Courtney R. Cannon (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Richard Chapman representing Courtney Cannon

17-11389-M
 
Darren Len Miles (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee

ISSUES: Motion to Dismiss Pending
   Wesley Thompson representing Darren Miles

17-11399-M
 
Rebecca A Solis (Ch.13)
1) Confirmation Hearing;
Rebecca Solis, ProSe representing Rebecca Solis

2) Debtor's Application for Individuals to Pay the Filing Fee in Installments
Rebecca Solis, ProSe representing Rebecca Solis
   
 

MOTIONS TO DISMISS

 
02:05 PM

12-12281-M
 
Donald C. Groat, Jr. (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Richard Chapman representing Donald Groat

12-13228-M
 
MILJA MICHELLE GREEN (Ch.13)
1) Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
2) Debtor's Motion for Entry of Hardship Discharge; Objection by Trustee
   Ron Brown representing MILJA GREEN

13-11511-M
 
Roy Roscoe Burleson (Ch.13)
1st Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Ron Brown representing Roy Burleson

13-11537-M
 
Kimberly Dawn Thompson (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Dana McDaniel representing Kimberly Thompson

13-12027-M
 
Carroll E Lockhart (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Reply by Debtor
   Matthew Riggin representing Carroll Lockhart

13-12031-M
 
Anthony Glen Schmitz (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   A. Laster representing Anthony Schmitz

13-12422-M
 
Samuel Dale Adkins (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Ron Brown representing Samuel Adkins

13-12826-M
 
Vicki Ann Pierce (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   A. Laster representing Vicki Pierce

13-12987-M
 
Debra E. Simpson (Ch.13)
1st Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Stephen Bulleigh representing Debra Simpson

14-10285-M
 
Gregory Daniel Cook (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Dana McDaniel representing Gregory Cook

14-11119-M
 
Russell Dee Wilmoth and Kristi Lin Wilmoth (Ch.13)
2nd Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtors
   Ron Brown representing Kristi Wilmoth
Ron Brown representing Russell Wilmoth

15-10026-M
 
Thomas Andrew Mortensen and Carrie Marie Vanover Mortensen (Ch.13)
1st Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtors
   A. Laster representing Carrie Mortensen
A. Laster representing Thomas Mortensen

16-10477-M
 
Lillie Mae Reed (Ch.13)
1st Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Richard Chapman representing Lillie Reed

16-10792-M
 
Shane Randel Williams (Ch.13)
1) 3rd Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor;
2) 1st Continued Hearing regarding Debtor's Motion to Modify Confirmed Plan; Objection by Trustee
   Ron Brown representing Shane Williams

16-10932-M
 
Larry Ray Spears (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Brian Huckabee representing Larry Spears

16-11028-M
 
Dana Lea Phillips (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Richard Chapman representing Dana Phillips

16-11165-M
 
Emily Ann Bileck (Ch.13)
1st Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Terry Bigby representing Emily Bileck

16-12242-M
 
Allison Newfield Keltner (Ch.13)
1st Continued Hearing regarding Debtor's Motion for Order for Immediate Voluntary Dismissal
   Michelle Matthews representing Allison Keltner

17-10207-M
 
Nathan Phillip Moles and Danica Jenice Moles (Ch.13)
1) 3rd Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Response by Debtors;
2) 4th Continued Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Lake View Loan Servicing, LLC; Objection by Oklahoma Tax Commission; Objection by Trustee
   Dana McDaniel representing Danica Moles
Dana McDaniel representing Nathan Moles

17-10975-M
 
Dennis Brian Lease (Ch.13)
1) 1st Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor;
2) 2nd Continued Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee; Objection by HSBC Bank USA, National Association; Objection by Oklahoma Tax Commission
   Michelle Matthews representing Dennis Lease

17-10995-M
 
Jeffery S. Branstetter (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Richard Chapman representing Jeffery Branstetter

17-11088-M
 
Staci Lyn Mickle (Ch.13)
1) Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor;
2) 2nd Continued Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   Richard Chapman representing Staci Mickle

17-11484-M
 
Jared Sterling Nissen (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case
   Jonathon Burford representing Caliber Home Loans, Inc.
 

CONTESTED MATTERS

 
02:10 PM

15-10993-M
 
Joseph Steven Washington (Ch.13)
Trustee's Motion for Turnover of Income Tax Refunds; Objection by Debtor; Response by Trustee
   Michelle Matthews representing Joseph Washington

15-12043-M
 
William Ray Jackson and Lesley Brooks Jackson (Ch.13)
1st Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion for Turnover of Income Tax Refunds; Response by Debtors
   Terry Bigby representing Lesley Jackson
Terry Bigby representing William Jackson

16-10801-M
 
Ronnie J Luckey and Tanya M Luckey (Ch.13)
1st Continued Hearing regarding Amended Motion to Modify Plan; Objection by Vanderbilt Mortgage and Finance, Inc.; Objection by Trustee
   James Stamper representing Ronnie Luckey
James Stamper representing Tanya Luckey

17-10066-M
 
Brian Winston Bohannon (Ch.13)
3rd Continued Hearing regarding Confirmation of First Amended Plan; Objection by Toyota Motor Credit Corporation; Objection by Trustee
   O. Gooding representing Toyota Motor Credit Corporation
Scott Kirtley representing Brian Bohannon

17-10103-M
 
Anita Denise Robinson (Ch.7 )
**Case Converted to Chapter 7**
1st Continued Hearing regarding Confirmation of Amended Plan; Objection by Trustee
Laura Frossard representing Anita Robinson
   

17-10201-M
 
John L. Ellis and Julie A. Ellis (Ch.13)
2nd Continued Hearing regarding Confirmation of Amended Plan; Objection by Trustee
   James Stamper representing John Ellis
James Stamper representing Julie Ellis

17-10249-M
 
Dennis Lee Youngberg (Ch.13)
Confirmation of Fifth Amended Plan; Objection by Trustee
   J. Gallon representing Dennis Youngberg

17-10670-M
 
Justin Thomas Marshall (Ch.13)
Confirmation of First Amended Plan; Objection by Trustee
   Karen Walsh representing Justin Marshall

17-10820-M
 
Derrick L. Woodbury and Michelle Renee Woodbury (Ch.13)
Confirmation of First Amended Plan; Objection by Trustee
   Ryan Assink representing Derrick Woodbury
Ryan Assink representing Michelle Woodbury

17-10912-M
 
Andrew W. Bellamy (Ch.13)
2nd Continued Confirmation Hearing; Objection by U.S. Bank National Association
   Matthew Hudspeth representing U.S. Bank National Association, not in its individual capacity but solely as trustee for the RMAC Trust, Series 2016-CTT
Matthew Riggin representing Andrew Bellamy

17-10953-M
 
John Terrell Main (Ch.13)
Confirmation of First Amended Plan; Objection by Lea M. Wolfe; Objection by the Internal Revenue Service; Objection by Mercedes-Benz Financial Services USA LLC
   Heather Buchberger representing Mercedes-Benz Financial Services USA LLC
Thomas Woodward representing United States of America
Greggory Colpitts representing John Main
Sam Bratton representing Lea Wolfe

17-11002-M
 
John Nolan Thelemann-Williams (Ch.13)
2nd Continued Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee
   Ron Brown representing John Thelemann-Williams

17-11050-M
 
Craig L Barnett and Tammi L Reed-Barnett (Ch.13)
Confirmation of First Amended Plan; Objection by Oklahoma Tax Commission
   Melody Suess representing Oklahoma Tax Commission
G. Gene Thompson representing Craig Barnett
G. Gene Thompson representing Tammi Reed-Barnett

17-11083-M
 
Derrick LaRon Hill and Tia Marie Hill (Ch.13)
2nd Continued Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Trustee; Objection by Oklahoma Tax Commission
   Melody Suess representing Oklahoma Tax Commission
Greggory Colpitts representing Derrick Hill
Greggory Colpitts representing Tia Hill
 

MOTIONS FOR RELIEF

 
02:15 PM

15-10015-M
 
Donald G. Lambert and Kimberly A. Lambert (Ch.13)
Final Hearing regarding Motion of Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. for relief from stay and abandonment of property; Objection by Debtors
   Kirk Cejda representing WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.
Ryan Assink representing Donald Lambert
Ryan Assink representing Kimberly Lambert

16-10477-M
 
Lillie Mae Reed (Ch.13)
Continued Final Hearing regarding Motion of U.S. Bank, National Association for relief from stay and abandonment of property; Objection by Debtor
   Kirk Cejda representing U.S. Bank National Association, as Trustee for Structured Asset Securities Corporation, Mortgage Pass-Through Certificates, Series 2006-BC3
Richard Chapman representing Lillie Reed
02:30 PM

16-11182-M
 
Willa Dene Osbourn (Ch.7 )
Application of Ron Brown for Allowance of Attorney's Fees; Objection by Chapter 13 Trustee
   Ron Brown representing Willa Osbourn
 


WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 30, 2017

09:00 AM

17-01010-M
 
Broken Arrow Royalty Company v. Rampart Holdings, Inc. et al (Adversary Proceeding)
Telephonic DIAL-IN Bench Ruling regarding:
1) Plaintiff's Motion to Remand Action to Tulsa County District Court; Objection by Defendant; Reply by Plaintiff;
2) Plaintiff's Combined Motion to Remand Action to Tulsa County District Court and Motion for Abstention Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1334 and 1452(b); Objection by Defendant; Reply by Plaintiff;
3) Plaintiff's Motion to Dismiss Counts I, II, III, IV and V of Rampart Holding, Inc.'s Counterclaim; Objection by Defendants; Reply by Plaintiff
   Brian Mitchell representing Broken Arrow Royalty Company
Sheila Sayne representing Broken Arrow Royalty Company
Timothy Trump representing Rampart Holdings, Inc.
01:30 PM

16-10678-M
 
Sheehan Pipe Line Construction Company (Ch.11)
Telephonic DIAL-IN Hearing regarding:
1) Sheehan Pipe Line Liquidating Trust's Objection to Proof of Claim No. 98 of Joyce Miller Combined with a Request for Approval of Procedures to Settle and/or Resolve Such Claim;
2) Sheehan Pipe Line Liquidating Trust's Objection to Proof of Claim Nos. 54 and 223 of Zurich American Insurance Company Combined with a Request for Approval of Procedures to Settle and/or Resolve Such Claim
   Chad Kutmas representing Sheehan Pipe Line Construction Company
Mary Kindelt representing Sheehan Pipe Line Construction Company
 


THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 07, 2017

10:00 AM

16-10678-M
 
Sheehan Pipe Line Construction Company (Ch.11)
Telephonic DIAL-IN Status Hearing regarding Amended Application for Administrative Expense Claim filed by Old Republic General Insurance Company (Docket No. 678); Objection by R. David Sheehan, Jr., Sheehan Family, LLC and Robert David Sheehan, Jr. Trust (Docket No. 733);
   Margaret Anderson representing Old Republic General Insurance Company
Patrick O'Connor representing Old Republic General Insurance Company
Chad Kutmas representing Sheehan Pipe Line Construction Company
Sheehan Pipe Line Liquidating Trust, Trustee
Mark Craige representing David Sheehan Jr
 


TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 19, 2017

 

CHAPTER 13 DOCKET

 

FIRST TIME CONFIRMATION HEARINGS

02:00 PM

17-11402-M
 
Francis Stanley Narbut (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Ditech Financial LLC
   Matthew Hudspeth representing Ditech Financial LLC
Greggory Colpitts representing Francis Narbut

17-11405-M
 
Billy Joe Keeth and Sharon Lanaye Keeth (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Wesley Thompson representing Billy Keeth
Wesley Thompson representing Sharon Keeth

17-11422-M
 
Matthew Ryan Ferrill (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Greggory Colpitts representing Matthew Ferrill

17-11423-M
 
Melissa A. Mazza (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Richard Chapman representing Melissa Mazza

17-11437-M
 
John David Hamilton (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Bank of America, N.
   Kirk Cejda representing Bank of America, N.A.
Wesley Thompson representing John Hamilton

17-11442-M
 
Darryl K. Williams and Reba M. Williams (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Tulsa County Treasurer
   James Stamper representing Darryl Williams
Douglas Wilson representing J. Dennis Semler Tulsa County Treasurer
James Stamper representing Reba Williams

17-11448-M
 
Gary Allen Bookout and Teri Lynn Bookout (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Dana McDaniel representing Gary Bookout
Dana McDaniel representing Teri Bookout

17-11477-M
 
Mary Sue Robertson (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Kent Siegrist representing Mary Robertson

17-11484-M
 
Jared Sterling Nissen (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Jared Nissen, ProSe representing Jared Nissen

17-11503-M
 
Prayoon Randy Chanthavong and Manivone Chanthavong (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Greggory Colpitts representing Manivone Chanthavong
Greggory Colpitts representing Prayoon Chanthavong
 

MOTIONS TO DISMISS

 
02:05 PM

13-10745-M
 
Robert A. Huerta (Ch.13)
6th Continued Hearing regarding Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case; Objection by Debtor
   Greggory Colpitts representing Robert Huerta
 

CONTESTED MATTERS

 
02:10 PM

17-10362-M
 
Jose Antonio Martinez-Guardado (Ch.13)
4th Continued Confirmation Hearing; Objection by Bank of America, N.A.; Objection by Trustee
   Kirk Cejda representing Bank of America, N.A.
Ron Brown representing Jose Martinez-Guardado
 


THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 28, 2017

10:00 AM

17-10639-M
 
Curtis Lynn Edwards and Carolyn Lucinda Wooten (Ch.7 )
United States Trustee's Motion to Dismiss Case Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 707(b); Objection by Debtors
   Bonnie Hackler representing Office of the United States Trustee
Katherine Vance representing Office of the United States Trustee
Michelle Matthews representing Carolyn Wooten
Michelle Matthews representing Curtis Edwards
 


TUESDAY, OCTOBER 17, 2017

 

CHAPTER 13 DOCKET

 

FIRST TIME CONFIRMATION HEARINGS

02:00 PM

17-11519-M
 
Michael Dean Starkey (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Dana McDaniel representing Michael Starkey

17-11548-M
 
Joseph Glen Burlison (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Jason Toon representing Joseph Burlison

17-11549-M
 
Demitra Rochelle Hammon (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Michelle Matthews representing Demitra Hammon

17-11551-M
 
Kyle Andrew Correll and Lacy Berlin Correll (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Michelle Matthews representing Kyle Correll
Michelle Matthews representing Lacy Correll

17-11554-M
 
Rodney Keith Watkins (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Greggory Colpitts representing Rodney Watkins

17-11567-M
 
Jerome Lamar Heenan and Laura Lore Heenan (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Michael Van Tassell representing Jerome Heenan
Michael Van Tassell representing Laura Heenan

17-11578-M
 
Clayton Terrelle Glass (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Dana McDaniel representing Clayton Glass

17-11606-M
 
David Carroll McIntire and Cheryl Dianne McIntire (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Brian Huckabee representing Cheryl McIntire
Brian Huckabee representing David McIntire

17-11641-M
 
Brian Eugene Bergin (Ch.13)
Confirmation Hearing
   Greggory Colpitts representing Brian Bergin

17-11645-M
 
Crystal Dawn Wise (Ch.13)
#5; Meeting AutoAssign Chapter 13